Our Little Secret

Lindsay Lohan Avery

Ian Harding Logan

Kristin Chenoweth Erica

Jon Rudnitsky Cameron

Dan Bucatinsky Leonard

Jake Brennan Callum

Judy Reyes Margaret

Katie Baker Cassie

Tim Meadows Stan

Ash Santos Sophie

Henry Czerny Mitchell

Bobbie Eakes Cheryl

Brian Unger Paul

Chris Parnell Veterinarian

Melinda Tanner Ida

Mim Drew Susan

Kurt Yue Priest

Nathan Alexander Tutterrow Altar Boy

Jade Fernandez Holly

Kimberly Donyale Middle Aged Woman

Sunny Williams Church Lady

Leah Selene Nativity Kid

Warren Abercrombie Construction Man

Christopher Deforest Choir Member

Roy Jenkins Choir Member

Corrie Henson Choir Member

Janeen Michael Choir Member

Jasper Randall Choir Member

Kathy J. Carey Choir Member

Mark Blankenship Choir Member

Rachael Chao Choir Member

Rita Shealy Choir Member

Sonya Da Silva Choir Member

Steve Adam Henson Choir Member

Tim Ellis Choir Member

Wendy Young McKinnon Choir Member